Case Study

What is Google Zero doing to the news funnel?

A new Lenfest Institute series looking at how local outlets are rising to the “Google Zero” challenge and what lessons and inspiration others can take from their successes.

By Nidhi Prakash

November 19, 2026

FotoField / Shutterstock

A Google search isn’t just the first step in finding news anymore — increasingly, it’s the only step. Call it “Google Zero,” “The great traffic heist,” or “The search traffic apocalypse,” but the way people use the internet has fundamentally changed.

Where a potential reader might have, in the past, Googled “Who won the 2020 election,” for example, and then clicked on the first few links offered up, they are increasingly likely to instead get a neat summary generated by AI (though the quality of that summary might be questionable), which means they never have to click anywhere or sift through information on multiple sites.

“We can kind of critique whether or not they’re smart, or good, or accurate, but they are responding to a consumer’s desire not to be given a list of primary research to go and do,” said Jim Bernard, a digital strategy consultant and advisor with the Lenfest Expert Network.

One recent study analyzing SimilarWeb data from January through April this year found that 68% of Google searches did not result in any clicks on links to websites. The study, commissioned by marketing and audience research firm SparkToro, is indicative of the wider shift across all websites. 

The picture for news specifically appears to be similar, but more nuanced. National outlets are taking the hardest hits in terms of visitors and pageviews, but publishers of all sizes are suffering, according to Mather Economics’ most recent Audience Benchmarks report. 

The report found that by July 2026, the news industry had seen 18 consecutive months of year-over-year audience contraction. We have “moved beyond cyclical weakness” to a phase of “structural” audience losses, because search referrals are no longer a reliable entry point to draw new readers, the report said.

In this series, we’ll look at how local outlets both large and small are rising to the “Google Zero” challenge, and what lessons and inspiration others can take from their successes.

We spoke to a range of leaders, from those at major independent newspapers like The Philadelphia Inquirer and The Boston Globe, who took part in The Lenfest Institute’s Local Independent News Coalition, to small news publishers working with a minimal team to keep their publications afloat. 

What this looks like for local news, Bernard said, really depends on what Google search traffic means to each individual publisher to begin with. 

It’s crucial to take stock of how much of their audience they’re losing, and then understand what that lost audience actually signifies, he said. It could be that those readers who arrived via search were not converting in any way. But, for example, a publisher might find that some of that search traffic was bringing in email addresses, which could then be used for reader revenue.

On the other hand, he said, it’s likely that Google search referrals were not the most valuable segment of the audience for most small local publishers — so even if they have seen losses there, they might not be as concerning. 

“You have to know your funnel well enough to know what the impact to the funnel is,” he said.

Understand your audience and what matters to them 

There are no cookie-cutter solutions. But local news publishers are already well aware of these shifts, and some have begun adapting their approaches.

“Fly-by traffic is gone, and we shifted two years ago to double down on direct, lasting relationships with audiences who value our journalism,” said Lisa Hughes, CEO and publisher of The Philadelphia Inquirer. 

“We’ve been a daily habit for 197 years, so we have a head start with brand recognition and authority in Philly and the region,” she said. “What that means practically is understanding who our readers are, what matters to them, and that we continue to make The Inquirer an essential part of their daily lives.”

In a recent Blue Engine Collaborative/Lenfest Institute poll of newspaper executives, two-thirds of the executives surveyed said Google search accounts for a third or less of their traffic today, while a similar share expect search referrals to drop by 25% or more over the next 12 months. None of the respondents expected their search traffic to grow. 

“The traditional Google search model is broken, and we’d be crazy to sit here and think that it’s going to get fixed, ” said USA Today Co. (formerly Gannett) CEO Mike Reed, in an interview earlier this year. 

On the company’s Q3 earnings call on Nov. 5, Reed said changes in search behavior have led to digital ad revenue setbacks, and particularly that traffic losses as a result of AI summaries have hit indirect advertising, a relatively small portion of the company’s business. Overall, digital ad revenue fell 13.9% year-over-year in the third quarter.

Reed said search referral traffic “has historically been one of our lower-value audience sources,” and that the company views those losses as a short-term problem as they focus on other areas like digital-only subscription revenue, which increased 5.3% year-over-year, and revenue from AI partnerships, content licensing agreements, and syndication, which grew 24.8% year-over-year.

As media companies contend with their search traffic declines and try new strategies, publishers need to keep in mind that audiences are not just changing their search habits, but how they consume news more broadly, said Adriana Lacy, media strategist and CEO of Field Nine Group.

“It is the biggest example of the change in user habits, but I don’t really think it’s the only issue that publishers are facing right now. I think it’s the easiest one to blame, just because it’s easy to see,” she said.

“People just aren’t reading articles anymore,” she said. “So even if they’re not coming in through search, they’re also not coming in through social. They’re also not coming in through other channels that people used to traditionally use.”

So what, specifically, are newsrooms trying and finding success with?

The numbers are daunting. The Mather report found a 15.7% drop in visitors to U.S. news sites in the second quarter of 2026 compared to the same time last year, and a 12.4% drop in pageviews for the same period. 

Within this, however, Mather notes that publishers with “strong reader relationships” appear to be outperforming others of their size. And even as traffic declines, audience engagement has remained relatively steady across the industry. Publishers with “differentiated content” — unique content that only they can provide — also appear to be less vulnerable to search traffic drops compared to other outlets their size. 

This moment could serve as a catalyst for publishers to focus on building long-term loyalty with their audiences and drawing in new readers and viewers who remain engaged, rather than focusing heavily on fleeting pageviews.

Those connections are more likely to convert, whether that means sign-ups, followers, engaged readers and viewers, or subscribers — and have the potential to minimize reliance on search traffic.

How outlets go about strengthening those relationships might look vastly different for a small outlet focused on hyperlocal food and entertainment, for example, versus a mid-sized newsroom covering general news.

Hughes said The Inquirer is investing in personalization in its digital products like the mobile app. She pointed to Inquirer Weekend, which was launched to draw new readers by creating recurring features, encouraging reader habits.  It has also seen successes with AI-supported hyperlocal newsletters, vertical video, and in-person events like Inquirer Food Fest. We’ll look more closely at some of those in upcoming articles in this “Google Zero” series.

“The goal is to give people more reasons to come back, engage, and become subscribers,” Hughes said.

Bernard suggests that news organizations need to evaluate what content is actually working for them. Some newsrooms have begun using AI tools to identify what kinds of stories are driving conversions on an ongoing basis, he said.

“I would encourage small publishers to answer the question globally: what is converting for us? And the experience that you see … from bigger publishers is that there are pockets of content that are oftentimes counterintuitive or surprising that do convert,” he said.

That means knowing where your organization is starting from before deciding where to invest resources, especially if your resources are scarce.

“If your conversion is, ‘I need people to sign up for an email’, or if your conversion is, ‘I need someone to make a donation’. Understanding what content is driving that would be the first order of business,” said Bernard.

Lenfest Institute Head of Advisory Programs Cheryl Thompson-Morton put together a brief survey that newsrooms can use to diagnose how dependent they are on search traffic and where their strengths are:

The survey asks:

  • What share of traffic comes from search?
  • What share of subscription starts come from search?
  • What’s your search conversion rate?
  • What share of newsletter readers convert to paying?
  • What share of readers are known vs. anonymous? 
  • Which habits bring readers back?

For some of the folks we talked to, refining their newsletters has been a game changer. Others have seen results from focusing on expanding vertical video, launching innovative creator or personality-led initiatives, investing in smart cancellation systems to retain subscribers, and shoring up basic SEO best practices to mitigate losses. 

We asked what advice they’d give others looking to launch similar projects, and gathered expert insight on how to position news organizations to not only reach audiences, but to build long-lasting relationships with them. In the coming months, we’ll share more. Sign up to our Solution Set newsletter to get free resources, tools, and case studies in your inbox every other week.

Local News Solutions

The Lenfest Institute provides free tools and resources for local journalism leaders to develop sustainable strategies to serve their communities.

Find Your News Solution
news solution pattern